Judicial Branch Home >
2nd Home >
News / About Us >
High-Profile Cases >
Election Litigation 2008
Coleman et al v. Franken et al (62-CV-09-56)
Contacts
Filing Information, 651-266-8247
Documents
- Notice of Entry of Judgment/Taxation of Costs (6-10-09)
- Notice Regarding Taxation of Costs and Disbursements (5-21-09)
- Contestants Objections to Contestees Bill of Costs and Disbursements (5-21-09)
- Contestees Response to Contestants Objections to Bill of Costs and Disbursements (5-21-09)
- Order Nunc Pro Tunc (4-24-09)
- Affidavit of David Lillehaug Regarding Sanctions (4-21-09)
- Findings of Fact Conclusions of Law and Order for Judgment (4-13-09)
- Order - Other (4-10-2009)
- Order for Opening and Counting of Ballots (4-7-09)
- Contestees Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Lisa Marshall Manheim (4-6-09)
- Order for Delivery of Ballots to Office of the Minnesota Secretary of State for Review by the Court (3-31-09)
- Order Nunc Pro Tunc (3-31-09)
- Order Granting Peitioners Second Renewed Motion for Summary Judgment (3-31-09)
- Contestants' Opposition to Second Renewed Motion for Summary Judgment (3-19-09)
- Order Nunc Pro Tunc Correcting Order on Contestee's Motion in Limin to Exclude Improper 'Certifications' Under Minn. R. Evidence. 803(10) (3-12-09)
- Petitioners' Notice of Motion and Second Renewed Motion for Summary Judgment - filed by Dennis Peterson Case (3-11-09)
- Petitioners' Memorandum of Law in Support of Second Renewed Motion for Summary Judgment (3-11-09)
- Affidavit of Charles N. Nauen in Support of Petitioners' Second Renewed Motion for Summary Judgment (3-11-09)
- Order on Contestee's Motion in Limine to Exclude Improper 'Certifications' Under Minn. R. Evidence 803(10) (3-11-09)
- Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Petitioners Renewed Motion for Summary Judgment (3-11-09)
- Affidavit of Ben Stafford (3-6-09)
- Contestees Opposition to Contestants Motion for an Order Declaring Recount Rule 9 Invalid as a Matter of Law (3-6-09)
- Hand and Email Delivery (3-6-09)
- Memorandum of Law in Support of Contestees Motion for Involuntary Dismissal after the Close of Contestants Case (3-6-09)
- Notice of Motion and for Involuntary Dismissal after the Close of Contestants Case (3-6-09)
- Contestants Memorandum in Opposition to Motion for Involuntary Dismissal (3-6-09)
- Order on Contestants Request to Submit Voter Affidavits (3-2-09)
- Order on Contestees Motion to Strike (3-2-09)
- Order Respondents Request to Bring a Motion to Reconsider the Court 012309 Order is DENIED-Judges Hayden/Marben/Reilly (3-2-09)
- Notice of Motion and Motion for Order Declaring Recount Rule 9 Invalid as a Matter of Law (3-2-09)
- Memorandum in Support of Motion for an Order Declaring Recount Rule 9 Invalid as a Matter of Law (3-2-09)
- Notice for Order Declaring Recount Rule 9 Invalid as a Matter of Law (3-2-09)
- Letter to Judges from James Langdon dated 3/2/09 Regarding Potential Remedies (3-2-09)
- Contestees Memorandum in Response to City of Duluth Motion to Quash Subpoena (2-27-09)
- Contestees Reply in Support of his Motion in Limine to Exclude County Data Practices Act Certifications (2-27-09)
- Order for Opening Secrecy Envelopes (2-26-09)
- Petitioners Memorandum of Law Opposing Contestants Rule 60.02 Motion to Vacate Judgment (2-26-09)
- Contestants Opposition to Renewed Motion for Summary Judgment (2-26-09)
- Notice of Motion and Motion by Jeffrey Cox and City of Duluth to Quash Subpoena (2-26-09)
- Memorandum of Law by Cox and the City of Duluth Supporting their Motion to Quash the Subpoena of Jeffrey Cox (2-26-09)
- Affidavit of M. Allision Lutterman Supporting the Motion of City of Duluth and Cox to Quash Subpoena (2-26-09)
- Order Granting Contestees Motion in Limine (2-26-09)
- Motion to Withdraw Pro Hac Vice of Benjamin Ginsberg (2-26-09)
- Letter to Judges Requesting Permission to Request Permission to File a Motion to Reconsider Ruling Striking Testimony of Pam Howell (2-26-09)
- Contestants Opposition to Motion in Limine to Exclude Certifications (2-26-09)
- Court Order Striking Testimony of Pamela Howell is Vacated (2-26-09)
- Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Contestants Motion for Ruling Applying Feb 13, 2009 Order to Previously Counted Absentee Ballots (2-25-09)
- Contestees Motion in Limine to Exclude County Data Practices Act Certifications (2-25-09)
- Contestants Notice of Motion and Rule 60.02 Motion to Vacate Judgment (2-25-09)
- Contestants Memorandum of Law in Support of Rule 60.02 Motion to Vacate Judgment (2-25-09)
- Contestants Notice of Motion and Motion to Strike (2-25-09)
- Contestants Motion to Strike Certain Amended Counterclaims (2-25-09)
- Order Denying Contestants Motion for Temporary Injunction (2-24-09)
- Contestees First Amended Answer and Counterclaims (2-24-09)
- Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Contestees Conditional Motions for Partial Summary Judgment (2-23-09)
- Order Denying Motion for Certification of a Class (2-23-09)
- Petitioners Affidavit of Service (2-20-09)
- Affidavit Nauen in Support of Petitioners Renewed Motion for Summary Judgment Note: 183 pgs (2-20-09)
- Petitioners Memorandum of Law in Support of Renewed Motion for Summary Judgment (2-20-09)
- Petitioners Notice of Motion and Renewed Motion for Summary Judgment (2-20-09)
- Affidavit of Service via Email Breymeier (2-20-09)
- Affidavit of James Langdon NOTE: 149 pages (2-20-09)
- Contestants' Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion for Ruling Applying February 13 2009 Order to Previously Counted Absentee Ballots (2-20-09)
- Contestants' Notice of Motion and Motion (2-20-09)
- Memorandum of Law Regarding Form and Level of Specificity Required in an Offer of Proof (2-20-09)
- Contestee's Opposition to Motion for Temporary Injunction (2-20-09)
- Memorandum in Support of Motion for Temporary Injunction (2-20-09)
- Notice of Motion and Motion for Temporary Injunction (2-20-09)
- Order on Contestee's Motion in Limine to Exclude Testimony of King Banaian (2-19-08)
- Contestants Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Benjamin L. Ginsberg (2-18-09)
- Affidavit of Benjamin L Ginsberg (2-18-09)
- Affidavit of Service (2-18-09)
- Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Offer of Proof (2-18-09)
- Respondent's Request to Bring a Motion to Reconsider Order is Denied (2-17-09)
- Letter Requesting Permission to File a Motion for Reconsideration (2-17-09)
- Order Following Hearing (2-13-09)
- Contestants' Memorandum of Law in Support of Acceptance by Category of Improperly Rejected Absentee Ballots (2-12-09)
- Contestee's Reply Memorandum in Support of His Motion in Limine to Exclude Testimony of King Banaian (2-11-09)
- Memorandum of Law in Support of Contestee Franken's Motion in Limine and Offer of Proof (2-11-09)
- Affidavit of Service - Snyder (2-11-09)
- Order Establishing Hearing on Motions (2-11-09)
- Petitioners' Notice of Dismissal as to Respondent Morrison County (2-10-09)
- Petitioners' Affidavit of Service -Zoll (2-10-09)
- Affidavit of Charles N. Nauen in Oppostion to Motion for Class Certification (2-10-09)
- Petitioners' Memorandum of Law In Opposition to Motion for Class Certification (2-10-09)
- Affidavit of F. Matthew Ralph (2-10-09)
- Affidavit of Service - Breymeier (2-10-09)
- Contestants' Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Motion in Limine to Exclude Testimony of Professor King Banaian (2-10-09)
- Nunc Pro Tunc Order Correcting Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Petitioners Motion for Summary Judgment (2-10-09)
- Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Petitioners Motion for Summary Judgment (2-10-09)
- Order on Motion to Strike (2-10-09)
- Order on Motion for Leave to Intervene (2-6-09)
- Contestants' Response to Motion to Amend Answer and Counterclaim (2-6-09)
- Contestee's Motion to Amend Answer and Counterclaims (2-4-09)
- Order on Contestants' Motion for Summary Judgment (2-4-09)
- Order on Contestee's Motion in Limine to Limit Absentee-Ballot Evidence to Ballots Pleaded in the Notice of Contest (2-3-09)
- Stiputlation and Order Re: Absentee Ballots (2-3-09)
- Stipulated Order of Dismissal of Contestants' Claims Regarding Maplewood Precinct 6 and St. Paul Ward 3, Precinct 9 (1-30-09)
- Contestants' Motion In Limine to Exclude Evidence of Each Campaign's Prior Position Regarding When and How Rejected Absentee Ballots Should be Reviewed (1-30-09)
- Contestants' Position on the Number of Rejected Absentee in Issue (1-30-09)
- Affidavit of Service Langdon (1-30-09)
- Affidavit of Service -Snyder (1-29-09)
- Affidavit of Richard D Snyder Regarding Motion in Limine (1-29-09)
- Motion - Contestees Opposition to Contestants Motion in Limine to Exlcude Testimony of King Banaian (1-29-09)
- Contestees Opposition to Contestants Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence of Each Campaign Prior Position Regarding When and How Rejected Ballots (1-29-09)
- Petitioners Affidavit of Service (1-29-09)
- Notice of Withdrawal by Petitioners Girtz, Johnson and Koehnen (1-29-09)
- Affidavit - Zoll (1-29-09)
- Pet. Second Amended Notice of Motion and Motion for Summary Judgment (1-29-09)
- Contestants' Witness List Trial (1-27-09)
- Exhibit List (1-27-09)
- Affidavit of Service - Stalock (1-27-09)
-
-
-
-
- Contestants' Opposition to Motion in Limine (1-26-09)
- Affidavit of James R Gelbmann - Regarding Ballot of Evelyn Koehnen (1-26-09)
- Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Contestee Frankens Motion for Partial Summary Judgment on Certain of Contestants Claims (1-23-09)
- Memorandum Contestants Memorandum of Law in Response to Contestees Conditional Motion for Partial Summary Judgment on Certain of Contestees Counterclaims (1-23-09)
- Affidavit of Service via Email - Breymeier (1-23-09)
- Affidavit of Joseph S Friedberg - Regarding Absentee Ballots (1-23-09)
- Memorandum of Law - Keeping Case Class Action (1-23-09)
- Notice of Motion and Motion (1-23-09)
- Second affidavit of James K Langdon- 41 pages (1-23-09)
- Rule 56.06 Affidavit of John Rock- 112 pages (1-23-09)
- Affidavit of service - Breymeier (1-23-09)
- Contestants Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Motion to Strike Unsupported Claims (1-23-09)
- Affidavit of John Rock - Response to Contestees Conditional Motion (1-23-09)
- Contestants Memorandum of Law in Response to Petition Motion for Summary Judgment (1-23-09)
- Contestants Response to Notice of Intervention of the Happe Interenors-They So Not Object (1-23-09)
- Order - Contestee Shall File Objection to the Notice of Intervention Filed (1-23-09)
- Order - relating to Inspection of Ballots and Other Relief with attached Memorandum (1-23-09)
- Notice of Intervention - Paul Happe,Eugene C Markman,Sharon Cook,Joel Gregory Uldrych, Claudia Bernstein, Michael J Hall and Sehwah Maggie Phillips-for an order to grant intervention-their votes were not counted (1-22-09)
- Order to Ensure Proceedings will be Conducted in an Orderly Manner Consistent with Minnesota Law and Court Rules (1-22-09)
- Certified Copy Order Motion of Norm Coleman to intervene-GRANTED Petition to File Proof of Service and Certified Documents to be sent to Dist.Ct. to be included in 62-CV-09-56 (1-22-09)
- Certified Copy of Affidavit of Charles N Nauen in Support of Petition by Certain MN Voters to Have their Votes Counted Pursuant to Mn.Stat 204B.44- 60 pages (1-22-09)
- Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Contestants Motion for Summary Judgment- (Filed by Franken) (1-22-09)
- Affidavit of C Chris Sautter-Atty/Recount Consultant with Al Franken Campaign-Tells of his Responsibilities (1-22-09)
- Affidavit of David L Lillehaug-Atty for Al Franken (1-22-09)
- Certifed Copy Affidavits of Service (1-22-09)
- Certifed Copy Affidavits of Service (1-22-09)
- Affidavit of Service (1-22-09)
- Certified Copy-Affidavits of Service (1-22-09)
- Certified Copy-Appellate Court-Motion of Norm Coleman to Intervene-Dennis Peterson, etal case (1-22-09)
- Certified Copy-Notice of Case Filing from Supreme Court-Assigning Case File Number A090065 (1-22-09)
- Petition by Certain MN Voters to have their Votes Counted Pursuant to Mn.Stat.204B.44 (1-22-09)
- Affidavit/Declaration of Marilyn Borgen-regarding absentee ballot not being counted (1-22-09)
- Affidavit/Declaration of Shirley M Vandyck- Regarding Her Absentee Ballot not being Counted (1-22-09)
- Order on Contestee's Motion to Dismiss (1-22-09)
- Affidavit of Matthew W Haapoja - Counsel for Contestants (1-22-09)
- Stipulated Protective Order- 75 pages (1-22-09)
- Petitioners' Amended Notice of Motion and Motion for Summary Judgment (1-22-09)
- Verified Petition For Appointment of Inspectors (1-22-09)
- Contestants' Answer to Counterclaims (1-21-09)
- Amended Certificate of Representation and Parties (1-21-09)
- Contestants' Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Motion to Dismiss (1-21-09)
- Affidavit - Of Charles N Nauen in Support of Petioners' Motion for Summary Judgment (1-21-09)
- Petitioners' Notice of Motion and Motion for Summary Judgment (1-21-09)
- Affidavit of John Rock - In Support of Contestants Motion for Summary Judgment (1-21-09)
- Contestants Notice of Motion for Leave to Exceed Page Limitations (1-21-09)
- Motion - Contestants Notice of Motion for Summary Judgment (1-21-09)
- Contestants' Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment- 54 pages (1-21-09)
- Petitioners' Affidavit of Service - Zoll (1-21-09)
- Affidavit of James K Langdon (1-21-09)
- Affidavit of Service via Email - Breymeier (1-21-09)
- Contestee Franken's Not. of Mot., Motion to Strike Unsupported Claims, and Points and Authorities (1-21-09)
- Affidavit of Hamilton in Support of Contestee Franken's Conditional Motion for Partial Summary Judgment on Certain of Contestee's Counterclaims (1-21-09)
- Contestants' Notice of Motion and Motion for Order Directing Counties and Municipalities
Possessing Original Rejected Absentee Ballots To Deposit Originals with the Court (1-21-09)
- Memorandum of Law in Support of Contestee Franken's Conditional Motion for Partial Summary Judgment of Certain of Contestee's Counterclaims (1-21-09)
- Notice of Hearing and Conditional Motion for Partial Summary Judgment of Certain of Contestee's Counterclaims (1-21-09)
- Affidavit of Patterson in Support of Contestee's Franken's Conditional Motion for Partial Summary Judgment of Certain of Contestants' Claims- 76 pages (1-21-09)
- Memorandum of Law in Support of Contestee Franken's Conditional Motion for Partial Summary Judgment on Certain of Contestants' Claims (1-21-09)
- Notice of Hearing and Conditional Motion for Partial Summary Judgment of Certain of Contestants' Claims (1-21-09)
- Contestee's Memorandum in Oppostion to Motion for Order Directing Secretary of State to Deposit Original Documents with the Court (1-21-09)
- Petitioners Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Dennis Peterson Case filing) to have votes counted - absentee voters (1-21-09)
- Affidavit of Service for Contestee's Opposition to Motion for Order Directing Counties and Municipalities to Deliver Original Rejected Absentee Ballots to the Court (1-20-09)
- Affidavit of Service for Contestee's Opposition to Motion for Order Directing Counties and
Municipalities to Deliver Original Rejected Absentee Ballots to the Court; Contestee's Reply in Support of Motion to Dismiss; and Contestee's Expert Disclosure (1-20-09)
- Contestants Notice of Motion and Motion for Order Directing Secretary of State to Deposit Original Documents with the Court (1-20-09)
- Contestee's Reply in Support of Motion to Dismiss (1-20-09)
- Contestee's Expert Disclosure (1-20-09)
- Affidavit of Service - Kirlin (1-20-09)
- Memorandum in Support of Motion To Quash Subpoena (1-20-09)
- Motion - Quash Subpoena and Protective Order (1-20-09)
- Al Franken's Response to Contestants' "Proposed 'Senate Election Contest Rules" (1-16-09)
- Scheduling Order - 1-16-2009 (1-16-09)
- Affidavit of Service - Kevin J. Hamilton (1-16-09)
- Affidavit of Service - Marc E. Elias (1-16-09)
- Affidavit of Service - Mary L. Peterman (1-16-09)
- Contestee's Reply to Proposed Schedule (1-15-09)
- Amended Order - Judicial Assignment (1-13-09)
- Affidavit of Service - Contestants Proposed Schedule (1-13-09)
- Supreme Court Order - Judicial Assignment (1-13-09)
- Contestee's Answer and Counterclaims This is a large document, please be patient. (1-12-09)
- Memorandum in Support of Contestee's Motion to Dismiss (1-12-09)
- Contestee Al Franken's Motion to Dismiss (1-12-09)
- Affadavit of Service by Email and Mail (1-12-09)
- Order for Admission Pro Hac Vice (1-12-09)
- Affidavit of Personal Service - Elias (1-12-09)
-
-
-
-
-
-
- Contest Motion (1-6-09)
- Summons-Notice (1-6-09)
Al Franken for Senate v. Ramsey County, Joseph Mansky, and John Does and Jane Does (62-CV-08-11578)
Norm Coleman and Coleman for Senate v. Cynthia Reichert as Director of Elections for City of Minneapolis, John Does and Jane Does (62-CV-08-11427)